November 20, 2026

Glass Lewis: Targeted Changes to “Four Perspectives” Model

A few months ago, Dave shared that Glass Lewis would be shifting its research approach to use a four-perspective framework: Business fundamentals, foundational governance, global stewardship and sustainability focused. In September, the proxy advisor opened a comment period to solicit feedback on its approach. Now, the results are in. Here are the key takeaways from the executive summary:

• Investors endorse the model. Two-thirds of investor respondents (66%) say the four Perspectives capture the major stewardship orientations in the market well or very well, and 59% consider them clearly and meaningfully differentiated. Every Perspective has its own constituency.

• The differences fall where the model intends them to. Investors divide along the very lines the Perspectives are designed to reflect, and most criticism of each Perspective’s distinctive features comes from investors who would not use it.

• Judgment and core safeguards command broad support. 90% of investors consider Judgment-Based Tests necessary at least to a moderate extent (66% to a significant extent), 58% reject performance-based latitude for non-executive director pay (19% in favor), and only 8% of all investor respondents want the Perspectives to apply meaningfully different considerations in mergers, acquisitions, and contested meetings to a significant extent.

• Reservations within a Perspective’s own constituency are few and specific. Only 24% of Global Stewardship investors support AGAINST policy outcomes based on disclosure gaps alone to a significant extent, and investors in every group, including those identifying with Business Fundamentals, see relative TSR as relevant but insufficient as the sole performance measure.

• Issuers welcome the transparency but are wary of complexity. Their views on the model as a whole closely mirror those of investors, but none supports disclosure-based AGAINST policy outcomes under Global Stewardship to a significant extent, and 74% support them only to a limited extent or not at all.

• The response is a targeted refinement, not a redesign. We will retain the model’s architecture and its four Perspectives, replace the relative-TSR-only High-Performing test with a broader Performance Assessment, treat disclosure gaps and missing sustainability factors in pay as concerns rather than automatic triggers for an AGAINST policy outcome, and rename Business Fundamentals “Performance Focused.”

The percentages above are based on 121 survey responses. Glass Lewis also received written comments, which didn’t translate into the percentage calculation. Here’s the summary of issuer-side feedback:

Corporate issuers submitted some of the most detailed responses. They welcomed the transparency the model brings to differing investor expectations, and their views on the model as a whole closely mirror those of investors. Their principal concern is complexity: assessing the same proposal through four lenses with potentially conflicting outcomes. Issuers are also markedly more skeptical of sustainability-related escalation; none supports disclosure-based AGAINST policy outcomes under Global Stewardship to a significant extent, and 74% support them only to a limited extent or not at all. By contrast, they are more supportive than investors of High-Performing flexibility (42% against 28%) and of the harm-based approach to materiality (63% against 48%).

Because the Perspectives exist to reflect investors’ stewardship choices, issuers’ views have not been used to decide between them, but their feedback is an important guide to making the model predictable and workable.

And here’s more detail on the changes that Glass Lewis is making following the consultation period:

• A broader performance test: Business Fundamentals will be re-articulated as a performance-informed philosophy built on the same governance foundation as Foundational Governance, and the relative-TSR-only High-Performing test will be replaced by a Performance Assessment based on an advisory Performance Scorecard. It anchors on relative TSR, adds other financial and operating measures, and informs the analyst’s judgment. The Performance Assessment considers company performance across several periods, including the current CEO’s tenure. Where the CEO has been in the role for less than two years, the tenure period is given no weight and the assessment relies on the three- and five-year periods, which reduces sensitivity to CEO succession. In deciding whether a company qualifies for latitude, analysts will also consider the context of the succession process.

• Proportionate escalation: Inadequate disclosure of board-level environmental and social oversight under Global Stewardship, and the absence of sustainability factors from variable pay under Sustainability Focused, will be treated as concerns rather than automatic triggers for an AGAINST policy outcome. New Judgment Based Tests will assess whether they point to a more fundamental failure.

• A more forward-looking materiality bar: Under Business Fundamentals and Foundational Governance, the harm-based approach will be extended to evident harm, whether or not yet fully realized, while remaining deliberately demanding.

• Clearer terminology: Business Fundamentals will be renamed “Performance Focused,” Breach Indicators will become “Alignment Indicators,” and every Test will be framed as a question answered “Yes” or “No.”

• Greater transparency: We will define the scope and limits of analyst discretion, set a specific threshold for “meaningful dissent,” and carry forward requests for research that shows which Perspectives, Tests, and judgments drive each policy outcome.

• Core design retained: We will keep four Perspectives built on a common foundation of 18 Principles, a formal role for relative performance in Business Fundamentals only, the published High-Performing exemptions and the exclusion of performance-based awards for non-executive directors, differentiated treatment of materiality and board diversity, and a common core for Special Situations, to which Sustainability Focused adds a Judgment-Based Test of stakeholder impacts. We will also make clearer which Topics are and are not eligible for High-Performing latitude.

• Market context and shareholder proposals: The market-specific guidelines will retain regional calibration, and the market-specific points raised have been referred to our regional teams. We will keep the treatment of shareholder proposals under review and update the US guidelines as the legal framework evolves, including in light of the SEC’s proposal to rescind Rule 14a-8.

The Four Perspectives will replace the single benchmark policy following the 2027 proxy season. Over the coming months, Glass Lewis will finalize the global and market-specific guidelines and provide further guidance and illustrative examples ahead of implementation.

– Liz Dunshee

Take Me Back to the Main Blog Page

Blog Preferences: Subscribe, unsubscribe, or change the frequency of email notifications for this blog.

UPDATE EMAIL PREFERENCES

Try Out The Full Member Experience: Not a member of TheCorporateCounsel.net? Start a free trial to explore the benefits of membership.

START MY FREE TRIAL