November 5, 2014
SCOTUS: Oral Arguments in Omnicare
On Monday, the Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Omnicare v. The Laborers District Council Construction Industry Pension Fund, No. 13-435, to decide the standard of liability for statements of opinion. Is it enough for a plaintiff to show that a statement of opinion was incorrect or lacked a reasonable basis? Or should a plaintiff also be required to show that the opinion was subjectively false? Liability under that standard would turn on whether the speaker sincerely believed the opinion or not. This MoFo memo covers what was argued in the briefs filed – as well as summarizes what transpired during oral argument. And here’s the analysis from the SCOTUS Blog that the court is likely to affirm – and analysis from Lane Powell’s Claire Loebs Davis…
Securities Class Actions: Gutting the Loss Causation Requirement
As noted in this Akin Gump blog by Michelle Reed, “securities class action plaintiffs generally consider the conservative 5th Circuit to be shark infested waters for pursuing federal securities claims, with very rigorous pleading and proof standards imposed with exactness. After a ruling in Public Employees’ Retirement System of Mississippi v. Amedisys, Inc. (5th Cir. Oct. 2, 2014), plaintiffs may consider the waters slightly less dangerous. In Amedisys, the Court held that a series of five partial disclosures spanning two years may be considered together to plead loss causation.” Read the blog for more…
Also see this Reuters article which notes that US District Judge Jed Rakoff has warned of the SEC’s growing use of administrative proceedings to handle securities fraud cases poses “dangers” to the impartial development of the law.
SEC Sanctions Auditor & Requires Lead Partner Rotation
As noted in this blog by Brooks Pierce’s David Smyth, the SEC’s recent administrative action against an independent auditor should give pause to smaller companies. The SEC required the auditor to rotate its lead partners on its engagements with clients…
This CFO.com blog entitled “The Split Over Convergence” covers how the FASB and IASB backed away from the goal of a single global accounting language…
– Broc Romanek