November 20, 2026
Conflict Minerals Rule: National Security Threat?
The SEC’s conflict mineral rule is often “Exhibit A” for anyone arguing that some SEC rules are improperly focused on “naming & shaming” rather than providing material information to investors. A couple years ago, I blogged about a report from the Government Accountability Office that found the rule may have done more harm in the DRC than good. Last year, it made Dave’s wish list for SEC rules to somehow eliminate.
For all of those reasons and more, I am guessing that the speech delivered by Commissioner Uyeda at yesterday’s ABA Fed Reg winter meeting was warmly received. In it, he notes that while the intentions behind the original rule were noble and bipartisan, it has not delivered the transparency it promised, and – as noted in the above-mentioned GAO report – it has actually been associated with the spread of violence rather than its reduction. Moreover, according to Commissioner Uyeda, it’s putting our national security at risk. Here’s an excerpt:
Tin, tantalum, and tungsten are all on the U.S. Geological Survey’s List of Critical Minerals.[13] When American companies step back, others step in, and Chinese firms have built commanding positions across the DRC’s mining sector.[14] For years, administrations of both parties have recognized that secure supplies of critical minerals depend on American engagement abroad, not withdrawal. Yet a securities disclosure rule stemming from a 2010 law still tells American companies that sourcing minerals from the DRC region is a reputational risk.
Eliminating a rule is usually an uphill battle – but in his speech, Commissioner Uyeda floats a couple of alternatives:
Given the current situation, there are options, ranging from repeal of the legislation to the statute’s own national security waiver,[20] to move away from the unconstructive financial disclosure approach set forth in Section 1502 of the Dodd-Frank Act and toward more productive efforts to address the humanitarian goals that inspired the original bill.
Commissioner speeches aren’t rulemaking directives, but they can give us a sense of priorities – and in that informal way, they sometimes serve as a prelude to coming attractions. Stay tuned!
– Liz Dunshee
Blog Preferences: Subscribe, unsubscribe, or change the frequency of email notifications for this blog.
UPDATE EMAIL PREFERENCESTry Out The Full Member Experience: Not a member of TheCorporateCounsel.net? Start a free trial to explore the benefits of membership.
START MY FREE TRIAL