November 18, 2026
IPOs: SCOTUS Grants Cert About Duty to Disclose “Flash Numbers”
Late last week, the US Supreme Court agreed to consider a question many securities lawyers and companies grapple with during offerings: Do issuers need to disclose interim financial information in advance of their quarterly reporting deadlines? In the case at issue, the plaintiff is bringing a Section 11 claim based on an allegation that the company’s IPO registration statement was materially misleading due to undisclosed interim financial information. This Sullivan & Cromwell memo summarizes the claims:
1. Plaintiffs allege that omitting the interim results render misleading accurate disclosures of past performance. In [this case], a divided Ninth Circuit panel held that if the interim financial data is material, disclosure is required regardless of whether disclosure of the interim results was necessary to make any statement made “not misleading” (as required under the duty to disclose element).[3]
2. For statements made in a registration statement (e.g., offering documents for an initial public offering), which are subject to liability under Section 11, plaintiffs contend that the interim results qualify as “known trends or uncertainties” that must be disclosed under Item 303 of Regulation S-K. On this issue, the divided panel in [the case] held, in conflict with other Circuits, that Item 303’s disclosure obligations are not limited to sufficiently persistent “trends.”
Although [the company’s] petition for certiorari raised both issues, the Supreme Court granted certiorari on the first question only—namely, “Whether an issuer can be found liable under the misleading-omissions prong of Section 11(a) … based on a determination that the issuer failed to disclose interim financial information that is material within the meaning of Section 11(a), without an additional inquiry to determine whether the omission rendered any affirmative statement misleading.”[5]
Check out this D&O Diary blog for more detail about the case and a discussion of its significance. Here’s an excerpt:
[A]nytime the U.S. Supreme Court agrees to take up a securities case, it is an important development – and not just because it is rare for securities cases to go before the Court, but also because when the Court take up a securities case, there is always the possibility that the Court will say or do something that has a significant impact on securities litigation more generally.
The fact that the Supreme Court has agreed to take up [this] case is significant, at a minimum, in the context of securities litigation involving IPO companies. The scenario involved in this lawsuit is, in fact, not uncommon. Plaintiffs’ lawyers often seek to argue, when an IPO company has stumbled out of the gate, that the company and its executives knew (but did not disclose) that the company was encountering difficulties when the IPO was completed. Often these allegations turn on supposedly deteriorating financial indicators that allegedly were known to company management but not disclosed to investors.
By taking up this case, the Court will consider the important question of what a court must consider in determining whether or not an allegedly misleading omission of interim financial information is actionable. Is it sufficient for the Court to determine (as the defendants contend that the Ninth Circuit did) that the omission is “material,” or must the Court also determine whether the disclosure of the allegedly omitted material information was also necessary in order for other affirmative statements to be not misleading?
The upshot will be to establish what courts must consider in making this determination, and, by extension, establish what IPO companies must disclose.
We have a section in our “Form S-3″ Practice Area that is dedicated to flash numbers in offerings that can help you navigate this issue – and we’ll be adding updates to it as the case law develops.
– Meredith Ervine
Blog Preferences: Subscribe, unsubscribe, or change the frequency of email notifications for this blog.
UPDATE EMAIL PREFERENCESTry Out The Full Member Experience: Not a member of TheCorporateCounsel.net? Start a free trial to explore the benefits of membership.
START MY FREE TRIAL